Ninth Ministerial Stakeholder Forum
The Ministry of Health (MOH) held the ninth ministerial stakeholders forum on 23rd October 2018 at the MOH, Afya Annex building. The meeting was chaired by Dr. Jackson Kioko, Director of Medical Services (DMS) and co-chaired by Dr. Amit Thakker, chairman, Kenya Healthcare Federation (KHF). This forum brought together different health stakeholders including Christian Health Associations of Kenya (CHAK), Nursing Council of Kenya, Kenya Medical Practitioners and Dentist Board (KMPDB) and Kenya Private Sector Alliance (KEPSA), to discuss emerging issues in the private health sector, the progress made since the eighth MSF, and the way forward.
In his opening remarks, Dr. Kioko thanked the private health sector team led by their chairman Dr. Thakker for their great efforts in advocacy and strengthening the partnership between the private sector and MOH. The DMS noted that MOH and the counties may not be able to provide 100% of the services therefore are very grateful for the contribution of the private sector. “Both public and private health sector should ensure that quality is at the core of delivering health services. We also need to train the health workers in having a good mind set, right attitude and good etiquette”, said Dr.Kioko. He further added that the human resource norms and standards need to be reviewed because they do not reflect the reality on the ground.
Dr. Thakker in his opening remarks thanked all the attendees for making the time to attend the forum and discuss Kenya’s health agenda. He emphasized that public – private dialogue is a two way engagement and PPP cannot be left to one party alone. Dr. Thakker assured indicated that KHF’s presentation on the role of the private sector will be shared with MOH ahead of Presidential Round Table (PRT). In the previous MSF, there were major issues that were discussed with much progress made including: Health Regulations – control of the cost of healthcare – it was agreed that implementation of the Health ACT 2017, including the Kenya health professional oversight authority will contribute towards control of healthcare costs; Regulation of doctor’s charges – it was suggested that a strong taskforce be formed to assess the doctors fees and procedures e.g. diagnostics, scans, medications, laboratory e.t.c. and give a report that will inform the regulation of the same.
It was agreed in the previous MSF meeting that KHF should be involved in the process of making Kenya quality model for health (KQMH) the minimum standards certifying tool in Kenya. Ms. Faith Muigai, regional director- Pharm Access foundation informed the attendees that AMREF has been an implementing partner and will share an official report soonest. Dr. Kioko reiterated that quality and standards is a vital area to focus on for UHC. “When it comes to matters of quality and standards, we are looking at collaborations”, said Dr. Kioko. Dr. Thakker suggested that the assessment starts with the areas providing low quality, then progress to areas providing high quality. KMPDB announced a joint inspection of health facilities, and requested KHF to send representatives to join the inspection team and give their input, to which KHF obliged.
Healthcare financing is very key in achieving UHC and the private sector is a major contributing partner. Dr.Kioko requested the private sector to present a well structured action plan on the role of the private sector. Dr.Thakker informed the DMS that the role of the private sector has not been clearly defined particularly in healthcare financing, because the role of NHIF vis-a-vis private health insurance is unclear. Dr.Thakker reported that KHF has visited seven counties to assess their healthcare financing needs and existing models. “The urgency of the counties is now. They have already modelled their own schemes and the big question is where does MOH see the role of the county schemes fitting. It is important that a risk pooling structure be clearly defined so that the private sector can engage”, added Dr. Thakker.
Dr. Kioko responded by saying that MOH is supporting the county financing schemes. “Although issues of sustainability and acceptability of the county medical schemes have been raised, we need to look at them positively and allow them to continue, as we look into how we can support them to be more cost effective” Dr. Kioko added. He further explained that the choice of pilot counties for UHC roll out was based on the need to cover the vulnerable first then the less vulnerable, and that the pilot will be a learning phase which will be monitored to determine which partners need to be brought on board.
Commenting on county managed schemes, Mr. Elkana Onguti of MOH however cautioned that too may pools end up in excessive administrative spend. Dr. Thakker then suggested to MOH to implement a regulatory authority that will regulate the schemes.
In matters of supply chain, KHF requested that regulations for appropriate control of parallel imports should be implemented. Dr. Siyoi, CEO, Pharmacy and Poisons Board (PPB) reported that regulations have indeed been drafted and are due to be gazetted in a few days. Ms. Faith Muigai, regional Director, Pharm Access Foundation emphasized that when looking at strengthening quality and standards, supply chain should also be strengthened. Mr. Onguti, reported that a legal framework has identified some gaps in supply chain though the discussions have not been finalized.
On price control of medicines, Dr. Siyoi reported that a task force has been formed that is looking at price reduction strategies, and he will give a report on this once the task force completes their report. The issue of coding of medicines was raised by Dr. Peter Kamunyo, CEO, Medsource Group. Dr.Kioko invited KHF to prepare and present a proposal to MOH on coding. Dr. Daniella Munene, CEO, Pharmaceutical Society of Kenya (PSK), suggested that Kenya should select the global language of ATC codes as used by PPB to register medicines. Dr. Munene will work closely with PPB on this, to propose a workable coding system for medicines.
Annual Africa Health Business Symposium 2018 focuses on achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC) in Africa
Africa has recorded a high increase in health expenditure over the last two decades with an associated increase in out-of-pocket expenditure for primary healthcare services. Access to quality healthcare plays a key role in achieving sustainable development goals (SDGs) and boosting economic growth. Integration of UHC as a goal in the national health strategies of African countries is becoming increasingly critical as the continent continues to bear the highest disease burden, an increasing population and lack of a strong health workforce to meet healthcare demands.
Africa Health Business Limited held the 3rd Africa Health Business Symposium dubbed AHBSIII at Hyatt Regency Hotel in Johannesburg , South Africa from 8th – 9th October 2018. The two day conference was themed “Achieving UHC in Africa: Stronger Together.” The conference brought together more than 300 delegates from over 50 countries, majority being African. A major expectation for the attendees was learning from various countries’ experiences in implementing UHC and the various policies and financing mechanisms required for UHC to be achieved.
The South Africa minister for health Dr. Pakishe Aaron Motsoaledi opened the conference by welcoming the attendees to South Africa. He further thanked the AHBS team for choosing South Africa to be the host country for the third annual Africa Health Business Symposium. In his opening remarks, he said “The concept of achieving Universal Health Coverage by 2022 is important. We should aim at reducing the burden on health systems in Africa”.
H.E. Amira Elfadil Commissioner for Social Affairs, African Union, said the public sector must work in unity with the private sector and commit to improving health outcomes for all, not just the middle, upper – middle and elite classes that the private sector mainly serves. “Universal Health Coverage, will help us narrow gross inequalities among people who require access to quality healthcare and affordable medicines.”
“Implementing Universal Health Coverage is only possible when we train local skills and bring in the right medical equipment. The private sector is well positioned to launch such initiatives through Public – Private Partnerships or tailored agreements” Dr. Mohamed El Sahili, CEO Medland Health Services.
Dr. Amit N. Thakker, emphasised that quality should be the foundation and basis of UHC. “Quality is the right treatment for the right person at the right time. The private sector has the opportunity to provide care more cost- effectively”, said Dr. Thakker, the chairman of Kenya Healthcare Federation (KHF).
There was an emphasis on strengthening public-private partnerships for achieving UHC. Intra Health CEO, Mr. Pape Gaye, emphasised that leveraging PPP in Africa can help achieve UHC especially establishing the right human resource capacity.
Key pointers discussed as a way forward were: PPPs, human resources for health, as well as quality and affordable medicines. There was unanimous agreement that African governments should consider working through PPPs to strengthen health literacy and health systems to increase access to quality health services and improve on financial protection schemes.
UHC can be achieved through learning from experiences of countries that have successfully implemented or are in the processes of successful implementation of UHC. Learning and adopting evolving innovations will give better ideas of effective healthcare models that are tailored to each country’s needs. Diversified approaches will create the road map to significantly expand the number of people covered by risk pooling arrangements, with substantial benefits to health care, optimizing resource use, maximizing results and “leaving no one behind.”
Dr. Toda Takao, Vice President, human security and global health – Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) – spoke of his own country’s post-World War II experience in implementing UHC. He said that it was the key economic driver to the country’s recovery from devastation by the conflict. Takao emphasized these three points: UHC is a nation-building issue, UHC is a pre-condition to economic growth and UHC must involve all stakeholders in the process or it will neither be achieved nor sustained.
Kenya Healthcare Federation was proud to partner with Africa Health Business Limited (a KHF Member) in making the event a success. KHF was represented the chairman Dr. Amit Thakker and two directors namely: Dr. Daniella Munene and Dr. Anastacia Nyalita. There were other KHF members who attended and exhibited at the event, including Corvus Health, IntraHealth International, Amref Health, General Electric and PharmaAccess Foundation. In his closing remarks, Dr. Thakker applauded the conference as remarkable, fruitful and very informative. “We celebrate three key successes borne out of the symposium: Meaningful interaction and engagement with dignitaries, tangible progress on unification of the private sector in South Africa under a federation with good will from the Department of Health, and a commitment from the private health sector to support African Union to achieve Agenda 63.
Many delegates visited a General Electric (GE) medical innovation center that features the latest high-tech ultra sound scanners, infant incubators and other ultra modern medical equipment. GE considers this center as part of a solution toward African development by fostering home-grown solutions. This includes an education and training center where expert healthcare providers train rural, community-level healthcare workers who are usually mostly untrained in the use of new technological advancements. There was unanimous agreement that the next AHBS (AHBSIV) will be held in Ethiopia.
The forth Speakers round table
Kenya Private Sector Alliance(KEPSA) held the forth speakers round table meeting at Leisure Lodge, Diani, Ukunda, on the 5th October 2018.The Speaker’s Roundtable (SRT) happened between the National Assembly and the Kenya Private Sector Alliance (KEPSA) and is one of the high level Public – Private Dialogue(PPDs) that was formed and formalized under the 10th Parliament. In her opening remarks, Ms. Carole Kariuki, KEPSA CEO, thanked the speaker and members of the National Assembly for the engagement with the private sector. She noted that KEPSA makes efforts to meet parliamentarians once elected, to enable them understand the private sector and continue engaging through parliamentary departmental committees to provide input into key policies and legislations.
Ms. Kariuki further noted the government’s focus on the Big 4 Agenda and emphasized on the need to work together to achieve the ambitious plan in the shortest time possible. She called for a change in tact and a need to re imagine Kenya through legislative partnership. She added that to spur manufacturing competitiveness, some of the underlying impediments that need to be resolved include; reducing energy costs, curbing proliferation of illicit trade and cheap imports, removal of IDF (Import Declaration Form Levy) and RDF (Railway Development Levy) on industrial input and machinery as well as enhancing prompt payments to suppliers. Through partnership with the National Assembly, she expressed optimism of achievement of the Big 4 Agenda.
The Speakers’ Round Table, under the leadership of the Speaker Hon. Justin Muturi, had some key areas of focus ranging from policy to revenue management to engagement with the private sector engagement. To note a few, the agenda included outlining recommendations and strategy for the conclusion of the list of policies, laws and regulations in the areas of revenue generation, debt management and effective taxation. They also sought to enhance the quality of policy and governance to facilitate a conducive business environment to create jobs and wealth in order to bring inclusive prosperity. Further, the Speakers’ Roundtable aimed to increase uptake and adoption by parliament of key private sector recommendations on the legislative agenda as identified by private sector and to increase coordination between the legislature and private sector on legislative agenda needed to drive the Big Four development agenda and to unlock private sector investments.
The National Assembly Speaker Hon. Justin Muturi applauded the crucial role played by the private sector in the economy as the engine of growth, creating jobs, paying taxes and providing essential goods and services. He said that interactive planning and decision making processes would be needed to support the private sector participation in development and foster partnerships strategies that combine skills, resources and ideas to stimulate the economy, enabling it to respond innovatively to national and global economic changes.
The speaker noted KEPSA’s continued provision of a unified voice for the private sector and maintaining focused efforts to create impact on wealth creation and social economic development. On the other hand, the SRT would provide an opportunity to highlight the key issues affecting public and private relationship and give the National Assembly a chance to identify areas of intervention to create an enabling environment for private sector development and increased investment. It would also act to enhance oversight of the executive to ensure all budgetary proposals are scrutinized and implemented as approved with ensure integrity, ethical values and the rule of law as well as promoting action-based best practices like corporate social responsibility, conservation and protection through prudent use of the country’s natural resources
During the breakout sessions, there were major discussions on universal health coverage (UHC) conducted by Hon. Sabina Chege, the chairperson of the Health Parliamentary Departmental Committee. Kenya Healthcare Federation was represented by Mr. Anthony Jaccodul, Vice Chair of the Health Regulations, Quality and Standards Committee. In his remarks he said that provision of universal health care in Kenya will not only accelerate progress towards vision 2030, but will also lead to realization of Sustainable Development Goal 3 of ensuring healthy lives and promotion of well- being for all the ages. There is therefore need for a whole systems’ approach in the delivery of UHC Mr. Jaccodul also presented KHF’s position statement on which includes; UHC should be implemented and monitored basing on quality indicators that can be measured by accredited Health Standards for Quality, Facilities to adopt both nationally and international accepted patient safety and quality standards e.g. Kenya Quality Model for Health (KQMH), Safecare, Joint Commission International (JCI),The sole government agency handling quality that is KENAS needs to be brought on board to ensure quality of care conversation does not get lost, KENAS would accredit conformity assessment bodies to implement various standards available in the industry, This would also provide a space for continuous quality Improvement, National Hospital Insurance Fund(NHIF)restructuring regulations to various sections of the Health Act 2017 should be drafted and guidelines adopted to ensure this moves in tandem with UHC.
The discussions were rich, informed, and resulted in several recommendations. There is need for a holistic approach to Universal Health Coverage. In addition to financing , we should focus on human capital, better health infrastructure, value chain efficiency, lower cost of medical equipment, standards for health services delivery and enhanced access to quality healthcare, policy on harmonization of pricing of health services to be developed and a review of work schedules in public hospitals to tackle the problem of shortages. There would also be need to evaluate of the Managed Equipment Service Program by the MOH to establish reasons why some of the critical equipment are lying idle and that the NHIF coverage in schools should be standardized to cover all students in both public and private schools including issuance of the NHIF card. The Hospital referral system should be strengthened to the lower tier county run hospitals to reduce burden on Kenyatta National Hospital and Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital. It’s important to strengthen the private sector for curative healthcare while public sector focus on preventive and promote health services. A health summit for all the health leaders including the Health Parliamentary Departmental Committee, Governors, County Executive Members and the private sector was proposed.
The legislative recommended the fast tracking of the Health Laws Amendment Bill 2018 ,by the house business Committee to the committee of the whole house. This bill will promote local manufacturing of pharmaceuticals and medical equipment to tackle influx of illicit trade in Kenya. National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) Bill to be brought to Parliament soonest so as to address governance issues i.e. separate accreditation and financing role of NHIF, Issues of quality management should be assigned to Kenya National Accreditation Service (KENAS) to accredit healthcare facilities and Ministry of Health MOH to oversight policy, Ministry of Health to fully operationalize the Health Act, Review Insurance Regulatory Act to increase uptake of private insurance in addition to the National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) and Finance Committee to review the public finance management Act to ensure that health finances are ring-fenced exclusively for health services only and avert diversion.
6th Healthcare Management Conference
The 6th annual Healthcare Management conference, organized by Medic East Africa, took place at Kenyatta International Conference Centre ,Nairobi, Kenya from 25th to 27th September 2018.The conference had three different themes for each of the three days. The first day’s theme was “From vision to Action – Reinforcing Healthcare Systems in East Africa, the second day was “The Role of Clinical Officers in the Implementation of Universal Health Coverage” and the third day’s theme was “Quality and Access under Universal Health Coverage”. The objective of the forum was to drive the region towards a health leadership infrastructure that is focused on perfomance and is held accountable for delivering on specific health system goals.
The conference brought together over 150 exhibitors from 18 countries. The first day conference was moderated by Dr. Amit N. Thakker, Chairman, Kenya Healthcare Federation. In his presentation, he emphasized that the key barrier to reinforcing healthcare systems in east Africa are; geographical and financial. Dr. Thakker informed the attendees that over 85% of Kenya population do not have any form of a cover and rely on out of pocket. 50% of the population do not have an access to primary healthcare and this set back results from poverty. He called upon all healthcare workers in attendance to come out strongly in health advocacy because unfavorable health outcomes such as maternal mortality are increasingly becoming a daily occurrence. Dr. Thakker further urged the attendees to capitalize technology, which is in itself revolutionizing daily.
“We need to adopt auxiliary health workers and also strongly recognize community health workers for the big role they play in health. The ministry of health should have considered hiring the specialists that we don’t have instead of employing what we already have because this doesn’t help in filling the identified gaps in the workforce. The BIG 4 Agenda is supposed to ensure creation of job opportunities and 5% of the jobs are expected to come from the health sector. Therefore I call upon the public and private health sector to operate in harmony to see great job creation and ensure good service delivery.” Dr. Amit Thakker, Chairman ,Kenya Healthcare Federation.
Dr. Andrew Mulwa CEC-Health, Makueni County informed the attendees that some of the challenges in the county level towards achieving Universal Health Coverage are: lack of healthcare workers i.e. the recruitment and retention of human resources for health is very low. This is because most of the specialists that are required in the counties, are mostly concentrated in the urban areas. Finance is an important factor affecting access to quality healthcare and is challenge because most of the population does not have a formal employment therefore cannot purchase or contribute to medical cover plans. This leads to over reliance on out of pocket expenditure. He however added that recruitment and retention of the health workers should match the county’s economical abilities.
Dr. Janet Muriuki, Deputy Chief of Party/ Technical Director – Intrahealth International was in attendance and said “We need to motivate the health workers, to help in reducing immigration. Assessing the reason for immigration, creating a favorable environment for them to work and giving them a good remuneration will also help in retaining the health workers. However, there is low distribution of health workers where majority are concentrated in the urban areas. Question is, are we taking training where it is needed? Are the specialist deployed where they are needed? This should be the initial stage in gap analysis. Technology should be a vital tool in this .This is because it can display the gaps in the human resources and distribution of health workers and track the training of health workers i.e. who needs long term training and who needs short term training. Therefore it’s important to deploy specialist where there is deficiency and not where there is a surplus.” She emphasized that the health sector needs to employ workers who are fit for purpose and the health workers should ensure they are safe in their working environment. This would serve as one of the solutions for curbing immigration of health workers. According to world health organization(WHO),the ratio of health workers to the population per county should be 23:10,000 in Kenya whereas the current ratio is still low as we stand at 13:10,000. Dr. Muriuki noted that the counties with highest health workers deficiency are Isiolo and Wajir.
Ms. Faith Muigai, Regional Director, SafeCare, Pharm Access Foundation reiterated that there is need to need to shift attitude and create a good environment for patient care. We also have to change the narrative if we want to see good service delivery. However, she noted that there is poor or lack of infrastructure to enhance this. There is no independent body that checks the health workers performance thus there is no competition that would drive quality of service delivery. Ms. Faith said that more health facilities should be accredited and the accreditation system need not be a pass or fail model but one of incremental growth. In conclusion, Ms. Faith mentioned that data is required to drive transparency and accountability, that there is need to leverage on public private partnership so as to drive the quality agenda, and finally that there is need to invest in proactive and responsive versus reactive solutions.
Some of the major concerns that were raised from the audience were: there should be an assessment carried out on why there is poor distribution of health workers and even lots of immigration observed among the health workers and come up with a solution. There should also be a safe working environment for the health workers because some of the equipment and medication used exposes them to the dangers of contracting infections or even developing other health conditions. There was a recommendation that the health workers should be trained on disaster management even as we assess the training needs in the healthcare industry. Participants expressed unanimous consensus that there should be capacity building among the leaders to enhance accountability on financial management and on performance of healthcare workers. The policies created should also speak to each other.
The 6th annual Healthcare Management conference was a success bringing together a wide representation of stakeholders. The presenters provided key insights into the challenges and opportunities in the healthcare industry while the audience contributed engaging and thoughtful questions and remarks. If these ideas were implemented, we would expect to see the healthcare industry change for the good of all Kenyans! We look forward to the next conference
Achieving Universal Health Coverage in the Counties
Kenya Healthcare Federation held county Stakeholder engagement forums in Uasin Gishu County, Kisumu and Isiolo County. Dr. Bola Tafawa, a retired KHF Director, conducted the forum at Uasin Gishu County. Where she introduced Kenya Healthcare Federation to the attendees ,in her opening remarks, she said “The BIG FOUR Agenda has helped Kenyans think on how to get the country back to business” She informed the attendees that, inorder to achieve Universal Health Coverage, quality healthcare should be accessible and affordable without financial strains.
It was noted that Uasin Gishu County has 80% of the population living in the informal sector, the poverty index is at 48% and 5% of the population is over 70 years of age. However, the percentage increase in private hospitals is higher than public hospitals which shows that the private hospitals are gaining more from NHIF. “Can we devolve Universal Health Coverage? Is it possible to start at the county level rather than at NHIF level and how can we be more innovative?” Dr. Bola Tafawa. The discussion was divided into three parts as follows: Bucket A – Focus on the 12% who can pay but are not paying ( find out whether they are willing to pay and not able to pay or they are able to pay but don’t want to pay.),Bucket B – pool the poor, Bucket C – pooling from the rich to the poor.
“People need to understand that Universal Health Coverage is not free and we need to look internally and think about whether we have the resources to pay. The schemes must look at prevention because we cannot afford to treat all the people. It is known that the best athletes come from this area, why do we not give more priority to encourage this? let us not think about NHIF only but also think about what model will work. People run away from the public sector because they feel like they are not getting the services they need and we need to address that.” Dr. Sitinei, JHPEGO.
“In the context of Universal Health Coverage, there is more of healthcare financing and it is well noted that NHIF focuses on curative and this may be a burden to NHIF, therefore, as a county we need to push for preventive care as we think of a model in Uasin Gishu and consider what is legal.” Maurice Oduor – Moi University.
“We need to be clear what we mean by Universal Health Coverage. I am representing healthcare financing in the County members. We know that UHC agenda is rolling out and in Uasin Gishu we have done assessments of facilities so that we are able to provide the minimum care. We have identified the gaps and now we just want to fill in. The steering committee is designing a package and we are thinking about what the minimum package should be.” Ms. Everlyne Rotich Health CEC – Uasin Gishu County. Ms. Rotich further encouraged the attendees to consider the innovation to put in place inorder to provide preventive care in Uasin Gishu County which should also be equitable and accessible.
The Deputy Governor, reassured the attendees that they are going to solve a lot of problems and save lives so as to achieve UHC. He further noted that the cost of treatment is part of the reason why people slide into poverty.
KHF further held a county stakeholder engagement forum, in Isiolo County, Hon. Isaack Abduba Fayo, leader of majority and member of health committee ,informed the attendees that Ksh.220Million has been given to the countie’s health sector. The Deputy Gorvenor, Dr. Abdi Issa informed the attendees on the important of strengthening primary healthcare and decongest the hospitals so as to increase accessibilit
Isiolo County has 38,000 households of which only 22% have a cover the only coverage is 22% of the population. The biggest challenge is the poor. There are 200,000 patients waived every month at the referral hospital. If Makueni care is to be adopted, 500Ksh cannot quarantee quality healthcare. However, National Hospital Insurance Fund(NHIF) is a challenge because 80% of People in Isiolo county do not have a formal employment therefore, subsidization is important.
Dr. Amit Thakker, Chairman, Kenya Healthcare Federation challenged the county health stakeholders, come up with strategies that will allow better healthcare he emphasized that they should capitalize on county stakeholder forum and Public – Private Partnership(PPP).
“Remember that if you improve healthcare then there will be economic development and you will be able to improve quality” Eddine “If frontier counties development council (FCDC) are facing the same issues on supply chain then maybe they can do group purchasing for the nine counties. Private sector would support this since the interventions would have an immediate impact” Dr. Daniella Munene, Director, Kenya Healthcare Federation.
A fruitful county stakeholder engagement was observed in Kisumu County. From a survey that has been carried out by the county in partnership with PharmAccess and world Bank, there are 160,000 households in Kisumu. 30% of the populations is unable to pay and the county government is planning to cater for the 30%. From a gap analysis and economic survey carried out in 2017, 10% of the population are from the formal settlements and are able to pay. 20% are from the informal settlement and may be struggling to pay.
Dr. Thakker, advised the county health stakeholders to come up with a better financing model that will also put the poor into consideration. Some of his concerns were; if a person is on low income and is able to pay for year one, what happens to the same person for the second year if they are not able to pay? Therefore, inorder to roll out Universal Health Coverage, The finance model should be affordable and sustainable throughout. He further advised them to have different levels for example, 1000 – 3,000Ksh. or start with what they can afford. Dr. Amit assured the attendees of full support from the private sector such as giving technical advise, actural support, banking model and others who will come in.
The Deputy Governor thanked Kenya Healthcare Federation team, under the leadership of the chairman Dr. Amit Thakker, for organizing the meeting.in his remarks he said “ This meeting has come at the right time, we have learnt a lot and from this meeting and our programs are on course and have been enriched as a result of the engagement. Dr. Mathew Ochieng Owili.
Effective supply chain will establish a strong road map to achieving Universal Health Coverage
Quality and affordable medicines is key in achieving Universal Health Coverage. However in Kenya the prices of medication is very high thus putting patients with Non Communicable Diseases especially Diabetes and Hypertension in financial hardship and others are not able to keep up with the medication leading to more complications.
It has also been noted that there is importation of illicit drugs and the government should be very keen in curbing this. How can the private sector contribute in improving the quality of medication and ensuring the medication is affordable?
Kenya Healthcare Federation (KHF) supply chain committee held it’s quarterly meeting on 28th August 2018 at KHF offices. The meeting was chaired by the committee chair Dr. William Mwatu. Supply chain falls in two of the president’s BIG 4 Agenda that is manufacturing and affordable healthcare. The supply chain committee has been pushing for the support of local manufacturers this makes the medicines affordable.
“What are the reasons that support parallel importation and what are the impact? One of the major reason is to make profit but this has a negative impact on patients safety” Dr. Peter Kamunyo, Director Kenya Healthcare Federation. “When it comes to the supply of medication, the private sector should use Public Private Partnership (PPP) as a channel to advocate for the pharmaceutical regulatories to operate within the law.” Dr. Anastacia Nyalita, Director.
There was a consensus on developing a unique identifier and best coding mechanism, for example each drug pack should contain original details so that when a patient uses the code to search on the details of the pack , they should be able to get them. “Therefore the supply chain should use PPP as a channel to advocate for this.” Dr. William Mwatu Supply Chain Committee Chair.
Recently, the Pharmacy and Poison Board (PPB) of Kenya made a bold decision to address what maybe the local pharmaceutical industry’s most controversial issue, ‘Parallel Importation of pharmaceutical products. There has been few attempts made to tackle this but not be successful, however PPB hopes that the current attempt will be successful through considering all important aspects in order to build a consensus among all interested parties in coming up with a policy position that is not only widely acceptable but also addresses most of the contentious issues once and for all.
The key issues to consider is create more incentives towards local manufacturing, change perspective and strategize on how to marketing for local products. A consideration should be put on what percentage off is to be given to the local manufacturer to give value addition. The main aim of reducing the cost is to increase on accessibility and not maximize profit. The committee will be pushing for implementation of the guideline draft act by pharmacy and poisons Board (PPB) Dr. William Mwatu was re-elected as the committee chair and Mr. Chris Masila was elected as the committee vice Chair.
The role of Information Communication and Technology in achieving Universal Health Coverage
Information, Communication and Technology plays a big role towards achieving universal health coverage (UHC). Basing the foundation on Primary Healthcare to achieve universal health coverage, ICT plays an important role in supporting, enhancing and accelerating the education on primary health care. Though It’s an effective means of developing workforce capacity, It helps to recruit and retain professionals and It is cost-saving. It facilitates social and collaborative learning which has great impact on patient outcomes, brings contextualized care to where it’s needed and It improves the quality of care by facilitating access to evidence-based medicine and reflective learning.
The ICT and Mobile Health Committee held it’s quarterly meeting at Kenya Healthcare Federation offices on 23rd August 2018, to contrive on how ICT can contribute towards achieving Universal Health Coverage. The meeting was chaired by the committee chair, Mr. Mark Achola.
Mr. Joel Lehmann from infospective research, presented on the data exchange and information exchange that the data exchange framework subcommittee has been working on. The main purpose of health data and information exchange is: Private-to-private information exchange – for more cost-effective delivery of quality service through continuity of care/ managed care, prevention of fraud, better equipment utilization rates, Industry benchmarks and indicators for business intelligence and advocacy with government which can also help for the design of viable reimbursement mechanisms and value-based care approaches and simplified private-to-public data submission which will reduce the cost of compliance with mandatory requirement and contribute to public health goals and health security (e.g. surveillance).
The data exchange framework subcommittee will; Help create the required political environment through: Identifying quick-wins and no go areas, Collaborating with industry leaders, Provide a trusted environment of common (rather than particular) interest, Help facilitate technology adaptation, Set up a demo-case of improved information exchange, Develop easy-to-understand documentation of government policies and investment scenarios and Support the development and adaptation of industry-wide standards.
The subcommittee outlined a road map towards enhacing the heath data and information exchange as follows; Make the case for private sector data exchange among industry leaders, including demonstration of analytics and high-level meeting, Practical documentation of current policies, standards, and investment scenarios (cost/benefit for individual companies) and Industry information meeting on current regulation and self-regulation, concrete steps required, benefits & costs for information exchange and Small-scale, fully functional information exchange with a selected number of providers/payers.
There was a suggestion that ICT committee needs to present key issues during the ministerial stakeholder forum(MSF) to this effect a public – private partnership sub – committee (PPP) was formed so as to present any ICT issues and advocacy during the MSF meetings. There was an election conducted for the new committee leaders and Dr. Tooroti Mwirigi was elected as the chair and Ms. Serah Mohammed Vice Chair. This was the first meeting under the directorship of newly elected Director, Dr. Daniella Munene.
The Private Health Sector to support Health Benefit Advisory Panel
As a way to expand access to higher quality health services and achieve Universal Health Coverage (UHC) the government of Kenya is looking at public private partnership (PPP) so as to leverage capital, managerial capacity and know how from the private sector. The government of Kenya is also increasingly promoting PPPs as a means to unlock financing and expertise in vision 2030. Important strides have been made in order to build the necessary regulatory frameworks and support systems that can facilitate PPPs to add value to the health sector.
Kenya Healthcare Federation (KHF) through Public Private Partnership (PPP) committee identifies the gaps within the public health sector and advocates on how to fill the gaps. During the presidential round table and ministerial stakeholder forum. The PPP committee held its quarterly meeting at Kenya Healthcare Federation offices on 23rd August 2018.This was the first meeting held under the directorship Dr. Jacqueline Kitulu and Ms. Joyce Wanderi. The meeting was chaired by the committee director, Dr. Kitulu.
The committee has held several engagements with the ministry of health through Ministerial Stake holder Forum. During the eighth ministerial stakeholder forum, the health cabinet secretary, Mrs. Sicily Kariuki, who chaired the meeting , emphasized on Universal Health Coverage as big task that the ministry is looking at and requires a lot of time and resources, of which cannot get from the government alone. “With lots of requirement in terms of time and resources therefore, this is where the dialogue around Public – Private Partnership (PPP) is important and we should consider the future of PPPs in this sector. It is important that there is one side from the private sector.” Mrs. Sicily Kariuki Health CS.
The ministry of health established a Benefits Advisory Panel that was tasked with coming up with costs and packages. The private sector was invited for a stakeholder engagement role. Dr. Amit Thakker – Chairman Kenya Healthcare Federation concurred with the CS where he emphasized that Inclusiveness is important as Ministerial Stakeholder Forum is made the epitome of Non-State Actors.
The benefit Advisory Panel invited Kenya Healthcare Federation that represents the private health sector for a stakeholder breakfast meeting at Sarova Panafric hotel on 3rd August 2018 to discuss more on the benefit package. It was noted that National Health Insurance Fund(NHIF) may be overburdened and cannot be relied on as the key financier for Universal Health Coverage however, the poor may not be covered. There was a consensus that the benefits advisory panel should share the package with the private sector, inorder to identify the gaps hence have discussions on how to fill the gaps.
KHF has held five county stakeholder engagements i.e. Kirinyaga, Makueni, Isiolo, Uasingishu and Kisumu to assess the financing models that have been established, identify the gaps hence advice on how to fill the gaps. There was a consensus on reviewing the PPP ACT and the committee should also ensure the PPP retreat should be planned this is because the health CS Mrs. Sicily Kariuki assured of her readiness to attend the retreat. There were elections carried out for the new committee chair and vice chair where Mr. Antony Okoth was re-elected to be the Committee chair and Dr.Christine Sadia as the vice chair.
Second Universal Health Coverage Conference in Nyeri
Kenya Vision 2030 delivery secretariat in partnership with Ministry of Health (MoH), Kenya Healthcare Federation (KHF), Amref Health Africa, Kenya Cardiac Society, Council of Governors, NCD Alliance Kenya, Kenyatta University and Nyeri county health department organized the second Universal Health Coverage Conference held at Green Hills Hotel, Nyeri County from 11th – 12th September 2018. The conference sought to address the non – communicable disease (NCD) challenge to the country and was appropriately themed “Universal Health Coverage for Sustainable Development – Transformative Solutions to Halt and Reverse the Non-Communicable Disease Epidemic”
The conference was graced by several dignitaries: Her Excellency Dr. Carol Karugu, Deputy Governor, Nyeri County; His Excellency Prof. Peter Anyang’ Nyong’o, Governor, Kisumu County; His Excellency Prof. Kivutha Kibwana, Governor, Makueni County; Dr. Julius Muia EBS, Principal Secretary, State Department for Planning; Dr. Racheal Kamau, CEC Health, Nyeri County.
Rev. Samuel Njenga of the Presbyterian Church of East Africa opened the conference with prayer and thereafter giving a brief address. He said that the church has a vital role to play in advocating for and sensitizing the people about good health.
Dr. Kamau welcomed participants and thanked the organizers for choosing Nyeri County to host the conference, adding that she looked forward to fruitful deliberations. “Nyeri County is facing a high burden of NCDs. We need to change our ways of practice and take up the challenge” she remarked. Thereafter Dr. Kibachio Mwangi, the Head of NCD unit at MoH highlighted the key objectives of the conference which were: Understand the NCDs challenge; outline the role of private sector in addressing NCDs; outline the role of consumer organizations in protecting the public from sale of harmful products; and outline the role of government, civil society and the youth in addressing NCDs. Dr. Mwangi emphamphised that NCDs are not purely a health agenda, but require a multi-sectoral approach incorporating sectors such as transport, education and agriculture particularly in prevention measures.
“We should put health first; unfortunately what are addressing is a result of our choices such as what we eat. Good health plays an important role in boosting the economy, reducing poverty, increasing education and boosting investment” Dr. Julius Muia said in his address to the conference.Preventive measures against NCDs took center stage in the deliberations. It was appreciated that more focus needs to move to prevention as we continue in disease management interventions.
The consensus on the way forward included creating awareness, education of the public and preventive measures against NCDs, adoption of a multi-sectoral approach, utilizing Public- Private Partnerships and supporting local pharmaceutical manufacturers to make medicines affordable and strengthening the supply chain. “Managing NCDs is very expensive. If we truly want to make UHC achievable, we need to address the issue of cost. If we reduce costs we’ll be able to expand the care. The biggest PPP opportunity in cost reduction is in supply chain”, said Dr. Peter Kamunyo, Director, Kenya Healthcare Federation.
Further, there was consensus that community health volunteers (CHVs) should be officially entrenched in the health system. It was recognized that CHVs play a very critical role in NCD public sensitization. It was agreed that NHIF be strengthened, that it should cover preventive health checks and that it should ensure that the poor and vulnerable are covered. The country should strategize on addressing the poor availability, lack of affordability and inadequate resources as barriers to UHC. Young people should be informed and sensitized on NCDs so they can act as role models to their peers in NCDs prevention. NCD education should be incorporated in the school curriculum.
A patient representative at the conference made an appeal to the health sector to address survivorship of NCDs, a phase of management that insurance doesn’t cover. She highlighted that cancer patients are usually deserted by friends and family after diagnosis due to the burden of their disease on their loved ones. “We are left alone. It’s time for medics to inform us how we can survive after diagnosis of an NCD like cancer. This way trauma can reduce and a patient can accept the situation, love on themselves and even achieve their goals. The price of medications is usually very high and almost unaffordable. Patients get financially drained while trying to get medication”, said Elizabeth, a cancer survivor of nine years.
Professor Nyong’o called on stakeholders to identify areas of inequity in health care, and strategize on how to fill the gaps. “Counties don’t have a strong primary healthcare system, the aim of UHC is to strengthen primary healthcare” said Dr. Karugu, while Prof. Kibwana called upon all pilot counties to learn from each other as a way achieving UHC uniformly, further adding that CHVs will play a big role in rolling out UHC, particularly in educating communities.
The conference was well attended attracting 400 delegates drawn from both public and private health sectors. There was representation from national government, county governments, World Bank, the United Nations office in Kenya, Non-governmental organizations and youth organizations. KHF was represented by the chairman, Dr. Amit Thakker, directors Dr. Peter Kamunyo and Dr. Daniella Munene, Dr. Joy Mugambi, deputy Secretary General, Kenya Medical Association (all panelists), as well as several KHF members who attended as delegates. A number of KHF member organizations sponsored the event.
China- Kenya Pharmaceutical Trade and Investment Forum
The China Chamber of Commerce for Import and Export of Medicines & Health Products (CCCMHPIE), held a trade and investment forum together with the Ministry of Health Kenya and the private health sector in Kenya on the 30th of August 2018 at the Laico Regency Hotel in Nairobi.
The main aim of the forum was to establish and maintain a good relationship between Kenyan and Chinese healthcare sectors and further explore investment opportunities in the Kenyan pharmaceutical industry. This forum was sponsored by UKAID and brought together participants from Ministry of Health Kenya, Pharmacy and Poisons Board Kenya, the Kenya Healthcare Federation, the Kenya Chamber of Commerce, the Economic & Commercial Counsellor’s Office at the Embassy of the People’s Republic of China, and the China Africa Friendship Association.
Ms. Guo Xiaodan deputy secretary of sub-chamber, department of pharmaceutical, CCCMHPIE, opened the forum by welcoming the guests. In her opening speech, she reiterated that she’s extremely happy to visit Kenya and establish a lasting relationship between Kenyan and Chinese healthcare sectors.
CCCMHPIE was established in May in 1989. It is the most internationalized and influential healthcare industry association in China the key areas of responsibility include: policy and industry coordination, conferences and training, exhibitions registration, consulting, market surveys and analysis reports in traditional Chinese medicines, pharmaceuticals, medical devices & dressings, biopharmaceuticals and functional cosmetics.
In his speech, Mr. Tan Shengcai, head of the Chinese healthcare delegation gave a background of Kenya – China relationship especially in investment. He emphasized that Kenya has been contracting China in building and construction particularly in road construction. There is need to have deeper engagement especially in the healthcare industry. He invited the Chinese healthcare delegates to evaluate the Kenyan market and see possible investment opportunities in the pharmaceutical industry.
Dr. Amit Thakker, Chairman, Kenya Healthcare Federation welcomed the China healthcare delegation to Kenya. In his speech, he informed the attendees that the investment forum is very timely since it touches on two pillars of the BIG 4 Agenda i.e. Manufacturing and Affordable Healthcare for all. He however emphasized that there is need to bridge the gaps in healthcare drivers, such as Human Resource for Health, Healthcare financing healthcare and ICT and Mobile Health.
The Pharmacy and Poisons Board was clear on their regulatory role in the practice of Pharmacy and the Manufacture and Trade in drugs and poisons. The Board aims to implement the appropriate regulatory measures to achieve the highest standards of safety, efficacy and quality for all drugs, chemical substances and medical devices locally manufactured, imported, exported, distributed, sold, or used, to ensure the protection of the consumer as envisaged by the laws regulating drugs in Kenya.
There was a B2B session thereafter conducted by CCCMHPIE where the China delegation had an impactful engagement with the Kenyan health sector, both private and public. The China delegation touched on business opportunities and engagements that can be established between Kenya and China. The Chinese team visited Kenya Medical Supplies Authority (KEMSA) thereafter.